Truly Livingston has always believed in happily ever afters, owed to her parents’ successful marriage of 33 years, and her career as a historical romance novelist. When she catches her fiance cheating and her parents soon after announce their separation, her world is shaken and she finds herself in a writing rut for the first time. In the middle of all this is a podcast Truly agreed to record in which she and a self-described realist give dating advice live to viewers. The self-described realist is family lawyer Colin McCory, whose views on love and dating are polar opposite to Truly’s, made clear when he calls her out during the recording of their first episode. Though she fully expects to not continue with the podcast, Truly returns after Colin makes an unexpected apology, and from there the show takes off running. In between recording and writing, Truly and Colin strike up an unlikely friendship lingering on the border of something more, and it could be, if Truly can convince herself she is worthy of writing her own love story.
Alexandria Bellefleur reaches soul-deep to deliver the romance novel of the year, filled with scorching levels of heat, podcast arguments, social media mishaps, and all the awkwardness in taking charge of your own love story. Truly, Madly, Deeply is hands down one of the best romance novels from Bellefleur since she departed from her Written in the Stars series. I initially had my doubts since that trilogy holds such a special place in my heart, but I’ve since learned never to doubt Bellefleur and this is further proof. I reread this almost immediately after reading through it for the first time, and I really can’t wait to do so again. Truly, Madly, Deeply is everything I’ve come to love from Bellefleur, open, honest, and so bisexual.
Truly, Madly, Deeply features two characters, a realist and a romantic, falling in love and reexamining their set ideals and agency in their own lives. It’s a beautiful story that burrows down deep and takes time to settle before consuming every waking thought thereafter. Bellefleur has written an up close and personal love story for the hopeless romantics out there, the people who have found themselves adrift for the first time and are seeking a solid landing place. The setup for this one was everything I was hoping for, a snarky back and forth between two opposites on a podcast, that introduces a raw honesty that is just what each character needs. Now Truly Livingston is a total icon and not even her embarrassing social media mistakes could have me not backing her up (because yeah, Colin is the hottest man to ever exist. next question). Her struggle with feeling like she’s not a good enough version of herself to jump back into dating was certainly relatable and it was a kind of reward to see her go after what she wanted and be proactive in creating her own happiness. I’m a big fan of right person, right time, even when our characters can’t see that at first, and this book absolutely delivered on that. All the little moments between Colin and Truly fueled me, from the impromptu coffee hangs, to late-night drinks, and impassioned conversations about biphobia. I just love them dearly. Truly and Colin were the epitome of bisexual chaos and their bickering turned full arguments turned back around to understanding was all-consuming and seriously entertaining. Truly, Madly, Deeply has reminded me of the power of connection and the strength that comes from our close relationships – of the happiness we can’t wait around for and must create for ourselves. It left me with a truly debilitating crush on a fictional character and a massive book hangover and I wish I could do it all over again.
Thank you to Edelweiss and the publisher for providing the advance copy.
Trigger warnings: infidelity, biphobia
Literaryrobin 
[…] in reading this new heist book. When I was catching up on some old posts, I found Robin’s review of Truly Madly Deeply, which was so positive that I think I will definitely have to pick it up. Lila at Hardcover Haven […]
LikeLike
[…] Alexandria Bellefleur wrote a fictional man so hot I considered jumping into the book just so I could date him myself. I settled for finishing the book and immediately flipping back to the start to read it all over again. Colin McCory the man that you are. Truly, Madly, Deeply was such a fun romance that at its heart is just bisexuality ✨ A theme I am clearly passionate about. I loved this bi-for-bi romance that draws off of first impressions and how they aren’t always accurate and the preconceived notions of life and dating that are actually holding us back from happiness. Truly and Colin were adorable (and so sexually frustrated) – if you’ve read the Instagram scene and immediately had to throw your phone across the room in embarrassment I see you. I feel you. I am you. In terms of fictional crushes, no one is really holding a candle to Colin right now and that’s so sad. I just want more bisexual men in romance who are comfortable with their sexuality and ready to lay it all down for one person. For more thoughts on this one, read my review. […]
LikeLike