Something about the winter season just screams fantasy to me so as the weather gets colder and the days get shorter I have been settling into reading more and more from the genre. This winter, the sheer number of fantasy books really popped off so this entire list simply reflects my inability to pull myself away from anything resembling fantasy or romance. But I’m mostly focusing my attention on underrated fantasy gems – books that I haven’t seen enough people talking about for my liking that should definitely be on everyone’s lists for the remainder of the year and beyond. A snapshot of these recommendations includes a rivals to lovers light academic fantasy, a fated reincarnated duo who can’t stop killing each other, a time travel do-over, a new twist on fae romantasy that includes talking daggers, and two brilliant academic fantasy novels.
Servant of Earth by Sarah Hawley
A magical dagger that talks to you and thirsts for the blood of your enemies? Say less.
As a proud romantasy enjoyer I am always on the hunt for my next obsession and Sarah Hawley’s romantasy debut is my latest. After managing to navigate the treacherous bogs that separate the fae and mortal lands, Kenna, a young human, is bound in servitude to the illustrious Earth House. Forced to assist the heir as they compete for immortality and control over their power, Kenna must outwit the members of the other fae houses while securing her place in their violent world. From the moment Kenna discovers a magical dagger in the bog with a thirst for blood and a tendency to beg for violence I knew this was going to be a unique romantasy. Playing off of some standard tropes, Servant of Earth is anything but typical. Our protagonist Kenna is clever and outspoken, as she navigates the fae court, unsteady alliances, and several romantic paramours (I am here to put forth the Kallen agenda). All I wanted for Kenna was to witness her rise after her struggle and it was so incredibly iconic to get to that point. She’s a legend, your honor!! I love the books that lean into the brutality of the fae lands and this is very much doing that while also exploring the longevity of war and living under tyranny. Book two is certain to be bloody and nothing short of brilliant and I await it most eagerly.
Buy a Copy:
Blood Over Bright Haven by M.L. Wang
Slayed boots the house down everyone is deceased.
With one of the most fraught opening chapters, M.L. Wang signified the true excellence awaiting in her academic fantasy standalone, Blood Over Bright Haven. From those first moments I knew this book was going to wreck me, but I didn’t know to what degree. Sciona, a young mage, has become the first woman to take on the mantle of highmage, but when she enters her new ranks she discovers more than the expected animosity with her peers but a flawed reality behind her city’s power that could cost her everything if acknowledged. Unflinching in its look at exploitation at the heart of progress and academia, Blood Over Bright Haven flawlessly details the descent into disillusion and Sciona’s rebirth as she resolves to bring the fetid truth to light. Part of what makes this book so brilliant is how frustrating it is to read from Sciona’s perspective – someone who while marginalized as a woman in academia, still benefits from the system in place and struggles to decenter herself when she learns the price of that power. The connection between her ambition, her underlying biases, and the desire to be seen made for a fascinating character arc, one that culminates in a rage nothing short of spectacular. In the face of this masterpiece, words really do fall short but it is brutal, powerful, and a necessary piece of fiction for modern times.
Buy a Copy:
Asunder by Kerstin Hall
I don’t want to lose you let’s merge souls bro.
Ever since she bargained with an eldrich entity, Karys Eska has been able to commune with the dead. Her latest job to uncover a ship gone astray leads her to the only survivor of the wreck, a young man named Ferain. Moments from dying, Karys binds him to her shadow, a choice that sets them on a collision course with the beings that caused the wreck and their divine allegiances holding sway – as she and Ferain become further entangled with the chance they can never separate. Perhaps the most underrated of the books I have chosen here, Asunder by Kerstin Hall is a fantasy triumph. With one of the most confounding and intense opening sequences, Kerstin Hall frames a world caught against a violent past and the uncertain future of a young woman turned Deathspeaker fighting for a future entirely of her own making. Its protagonist Karys, grasps for power in a world that has resisted her and rages against a terrible fate that awaits her when her contract is up. Karys’ vulnerability clouds the narrative and her fear of real connection, while frustrating, lends itself to her growing romance with Ferain and friendships with our main crew. The ending is SOOO diabolical and I need it to mess up more people!
Buy a Copy:
Sorcery and Small Magics by Maiga Doocy
When you’re cursed to obey your greatest rival who you maybe want to kiss a little.
A brand new fantasy duology that feels like a mashup of Ella Enchanted and light academia, Sorcery and Small Magics is a delightful foray into spells gone wrong and forced proximity between two rival sorcerers who team up to break a curse. Tethered closer and closer together despite their animosity due to an unexpected curse, Doocy brings together an adventure into an enchanted forest where two rivals learn just how much they can accomplish together as they work to break it. Our protagonist Leovander was an unmitigated disaster (affectionate) and I love him so much. Characters constrained by insurmountable family expectations who rise above them to cause chaos and write their own stories will never not be loved by me. This is the first in a duology that serves to set up the larger framework for the remainder of the series but it is a thoroughly charming start. Lot’s of bickering, romantic tension, and external issues to make it so that you never put this one down.
Buy a Copy:
This Fatal Kiss by Alicia Jasinska
A water nymph annoys the local exorcist so much he falls in love.
Escape into a whimsical fantasy with a smidgeon of meddling, and a heck of a lot of heart. Gisela is a river nymph, cursed to forever wander the river in which she drowned. The only way back to her human form is a kiss from a willing human. Luckily, the spa town nearby is full of potential suitors, but Gisela can’t get past Kazik, the grandson of a witch determined to excise the troublesome creatures in the town. After a failed attempt at exorcising Gisela, Kazik agrees to help her regain her humanity, yet neither of them expects to fall for the same man and the intended receiver of Gisela’s kiss. This Fatal Kiss has a cozy fantasy atmosphere that ensnares you in its depths as nymphs, witches, and demons wander and revel in the delights of a small spa town, and something darker lies in wait. The character dynamics are what truly set this one apart. We’ve got a fantastic grumpy sunshine dynamic with Kazik and Gisela as they begrudgingly agree to help one another, and Aleksey rounds that all out with his mischievousness and secretive demeanor. The friendships among the different water nymphs were also so sweet. I went in thinking this was a standalone, but there are several loose ends I imagine will be addressed in a later sequel.
Buy a Copy:
Our Infinite Fates by Laura Steven
When you’re tethered across every lifetime but you just can’t stop killing each other.
For as long as she’s remembered, Evelyn has not lived to see beyond her eighteenth birthday. Across lifetimes Evelyn has been hunted by Arden, a young man whose very soul is tied to hers. Evelyn has never been able to surmise why Arden hunts her, nor why they are connected in this way, but her current life has never needed her so badly – with her sister in desperate need of a bone marrow transplant that only she can provide. To bargain a way out of her established fate, Evelyn will turn to her murderer across lives for one final stand-down that may prove far deadlier than their connected pasts. Our Infinite Fates was an addictive thrill ride across various lives, and loves, of two complicated people tethered together by an unknown fate. Narratively layered with Evelyn and Arden’s past lives counting back to the truth behind their curse, Steven bridges a love story for the ages that stands against the fabric of time and asks whether love truly can win out against the weight of the past. The twists in this keep coming, unburied even as they seem fully excised against the truth behind this fated connection. Admittedly the final scene in this was enough to make me cry and the entire resolution was so wonderfully wrought you’ll be thankful for the tears.
Preorder a Copy:
The City in Glass by Nghi Vo
What if you were one of the angels responsible for destroying a city built up over centuries by a demon and she cursed a bit of herself to follow you forever
I am never shocked by Nghi Vo’s brilliance so this intimate expose into the lives of two immortals endeavoring to rebuild a city after its destruction was never not going to be an unforgettable story. Writing in the face of some truly iconic angel and demon duos, Vo flips the script with angels descending on a city to destroy its people and a demon who built the city up over centuries enacting her revenge and laboring to restore what was lost. The beauty in The City in Glass is in the passage of time and the resolve of a demon not wanned in the face of centuries. Nghi Vo brings together two immortal beings meant to forever bear the weight of the past and witness the hurts and triumphs of humankind. Vitrine, a demon, grapples with impermanency in contrast to her own permanency as an immortal beholden to time. The writing is a reflection of this, as years pass by and the city is restored but inevitably falls prey to violence and change. The love between Vitrine and the angel ostracized by his own kind and cursed with a part of herself was really the icing on the cake. I promise you will never be able to predict where the story ends but it feels altogether fitting for two immortals who have both hurt and loved in their own ways.
Buy a Copy:
Shoestring Theory by Mariana Costa
Cats, time travel, friends to lovers to enemies to lovers??? A triple threat.
Cozy apocalyptic time travel fantasy is a heck of a combination but Shoestring Theory pulls the threads together to create a unique and oddly hopeful queer fantasy standalone. Many years future, an aging Grand-Mage hides away from his kingdom now in ruins. His husband, King Eufrates Margrave, now rules with an iron grip and has descended into paranoia. As his days dwindle, Cyril casts a powerful spell that pulls him back to the days of his youth – before the death of the princess pulled Eufrates to the throne and madness blossomed, but unfortunately, that is not the only thing he brought back with him. Overhung by a dark future, Shoestring Theory feels like a one last shot kind of plot as cat transformations, old bonds, and future tragedy intertwine with one mage’s search for reconciliation. Rarely do I see friends to lovers to enemies that hinge back to lovers and Eufrates and Cyril were serving that to the extreme. The hatred was so powerful that I really believed these two were too far gone to ever reconcile, but Costa proves just how the past can be healed and these two, and others, can move forward. I really enjoyed the conclusion and who was really pulling the strings of fate all along. Very cozy and armed with a poignancy that had me floored.
Buy a Copy:
Rewitched by Laura Jane Wood
Oh no, the hot bisexual man with an impeccable sense of style and a tendency to announce himself in the worst possible way is tasked with keeping an eye on me!! Whatever shall I do??
Rewitched, part cozy fantasy, part bookstore love letter, and part romance is the coziest book I read this fall. I felt swept up in the magic as Belladonna Blackthorn, a young witch newly turned thirty realizes she must prove her worth to maintain her magic or lose it entirely. With the month of October to train Rewitched sparks a journey of rediscovery, with Belle’s interconnected past, her family, and her connection to her power reenlivening her way forward. Lucy Jane Wood thrilled me with a magical atmosphere that travels throughout London from the magical to the mundane spaces – all rendered with a remarkably vivid hand. The slow-burn romance kindling on the sidelines and the family bonds and close friendships really built up a foundation for the narrative and cultivated that sense of community. This was quite simply the coziest fall fantasy with a dash of romance to round it all out and you bet I will be continuing with the next novel set in this universe next fall!
Buy a Copy:
The Scholar and the Last Faerie Door by H.G. Parry
Good soup: another book exploring exploitation at the heart of academia
Four friends reunited in secret scholarly pursuits are torn apart when experimentation takes a deadly turn and old secrets bring it all crashing down. It’s 1920 and as England recovers from one the deadliest conflicts in its history, Clover Hill, a commoner, is admitted on scholarship to Camford a secret magical academy that exists to raise the next generation of magic users. She tells herself she does it for her brother – one of the only survivors of a deadly faerie attack on the battlefield during the war, but soon Clover is drawn into her own ambitions and plans that could wreck her newfound world. A dark academia similar to Babel in its narrative breadth and core friend group united and then scattered to the winds, The Scholar and the Last Faerie Door intertwines the worlds of the human and fae to expose the wounds of an established system built upon exploitation and the price of dissent. H.G. Parry adds new layers to this overarching conversation of scholarly pursuit in academia with class and gender unifying around the true cost of magic in this world. This character driven academic fantasy certainly stands on its own and should be talked about in conversation with other pillars in the genre.
Buy a Copy:
Literaryrobin 